Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

To: techdiver@opal.com
Subject: How many people invented aqualungs?
From: "A.Appleyard" <A.APPLEYARD@fs*.mt*.um*.ac*.uk*>
Date: Thu, 23 Feb 1995 12:52:12 GMT
  Many will already know that:-
  (0) Rouquayrol & Denayrouze in France in the 1860's invented a sort of
aqualung called the aerophore; it had a genuine regulator, but its spherical
`cylinder' could only hold 30 bars and was a baleout; the diver walked on the
bottom and was surface supplied. (Jules Verne's fiction story `10000 leagues
under the sea' used it without a surface air line and wildly exaggerated its
duration to 6-8 hours! :-) )
  The Seibe Gorman hardhat kit soon swept the field, and the aerophore
regulator was forgotten by the time men could make proper compressed gas
cylinders. (Else we might have had aqualungs and scuba diving since 1900! Alas
what three generations of our seaside-holidaying ancestors missed! :-( :-( )
  (1) Cousteau & Gagnan invented the aqualung as we know it in 1943.
  (2) Before 1939 in the French Mediterranean there was a scuba diving club
using constant-flow compressed-air sets invented by a man called Le Prieur.
But they were not available to Cousteau in the war. Before that there were
other constant-flow compressed-air sets industrial and underwater, but they
achieved little.
  (3) A Frenchman called Commeinhes invented a true aqualung in 1939 or a bit
before, and offered it to the French Navy, which accepted it, but the war and
German occupation interfered with that and with much else, and Commeinhes died
in the army in the liberation of Strasbourg in Alsace. But I read of someone
after the war ended diving with a Commeinhes-type aqualung.

  But in `Diver' magazine (UK) (March 1995, page 35) Barnard Eaton, discussing
the relative claims to priority of Cousteau and Hans Hass as the starter of
sport diving, writes "In 1941 he [= Hans Hass] visited the Draeger Works in
Lubeck [in north Germany]. His aim was to acquire suitable [8] underwater
breathing apparatus, and there were two sorts that Draeger could supply. The
first was an oxygen recycling apparatus which had been developed for submarine
escape. The second was a modernised version of an automatic lung, for use with
compressed air, developed in the mid-19th century [9]. Hass chose the
recycling apparatus because ...", and lists advantages of oxygen rebreathers.

  [8] Previously Hans Hass had used home-made surface-supplied diving helmets.
  [9] This sounds like that Draeger had developed a demand-supplied aqualung
in wartime Germany! Anyone got any more information on this? Was it ever
issued or used? Did they develop it independently, or from captured French
Commeinhes sets, or what?
  (So it seems that the innumerable war story comic-strip drawings of German
wartime frogmen wearing what are clearly Cousteau-type aqualungs, may possibly
not be so anachronistic after all!)

  PS 1: Re Hans Hass's rebreathers, I read that his rebreathers have the bag
on the back because he did not care for the appearance of having a breathing
bag on his chest (i.e. likely he disliked the `frogman look'). :-)

  PS 2: In the early days of diving in Britain, aqualungs were so expensive
that many BSAC divers made their own aqualungs. This may have had unexpected
consequences:-
  At a diving gear repairer's in Jan 1992 I saw a customer's early Russian
aqualung that had found its way to England. A thin manifold meandered and
looped from one of its cylinder tops to the other. At the middle of the
manifold the on/off tap pointed down the cylinders, on the back of where the
regulator screwed into a big screw-socket. Nowhere was the 'A'-shaped screwed
clamp so familiar in the West. The breathing tubes had cloth outsides like on
gasmasks. It had a pressure gauge. The Russians, on hearing about aqualungs,
may have designed their own from scratch; but it would have been easier surely
for them to get one from the West somehow and copy it, sticking to its tried
and tested main features, for they were no respecters of patents. Why then no
'A'-clamp but instead the big screw socket like on some butane cylinders? That
the Russian for aqualung is "akvalang", and not some word made up in Russian,
points to English, and likelier to Britain than to the USA. Since during the
Cold War the USSR would have got no official help from the West in developing
diving gear, did an agent of theirs, told to look in England first since they
had heard of aqualungs in English text, go to a diving club or diving centre
claiming to be an ordinary new member, and thus get an aqualung of the type
commonest then among British sport divers when factory-made aqualungs were
absurdly expensive in Britain? If so, it would be an ironic result of Siebe
Gorman's diving gear price policy at the time if the strange-looking aqualung
that I saw at that repairer's, USSR armed forces and organized sport standard
issue, was not Cousteau-Gagnan pattern but an improved copied descendant of
the BSAC's old help in need, an ex-RAF pilot's oxygen cylinder and a converted
Calor gas regulator!

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]