Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: cavers

Banner Advert

Message Display

Date: Sat, 27 Mar 1999 17:32:53 +1100
From: Bruce Stewart <bruce@tr*.co*>
Organization: Triton Dive
To: underhillp@ju*.co*
CC: AquaLad@ix*.ne*.co*, cavers@cavers.com
Subject: Re: WKPP Members
I heard George has gone really soft and went out at Christmas and
bought some furniture to sit on at home as opposed to oil drums,
scooters and tanks!


underhillp@ju*.co* wrote:

> Alfred:
>
> You think George is verbose and ill tempered now?   ...You should have
> read him a year or two ago.  He is definitely "a kinder, gentler George"
> these days.
>
> Regards,
>              Philip
>
> On Fri, 26 Mar 1999 11:29:11 -0800 "Alfred J. Alapisco"
> <AquaLad@ix*.ne*.co*> writes:
> >George,
> >From what I have heard of the WKPP it is an extraordinary
> >organization,
> >however, you have made a few detractors (for lack of a better word).
> >But, what
> >I have noticed is that you at times are verbose and ill tempered. Even
> >though,
> >your accomplishments should easily speak for themselves, you seem to
> >get
> >enjoyment in arguing the point with people who obviously know nothing
> >about
> >what you do. Every time I have ever seen anyone ask for information it
> >seems
> >to have been given willfully and freely, even though at times in a
> >rather
> >condescending manner.
> >
> >I am very interested in getting to know more about the WKPP and, if
> >luck have
> >it, see first hand how you accomplish the feats you are so well known
> >to do. I
> >do question the premise of DIR. I have always been taught that what is
> >right
> >for me is not always right for you. I, of course, do not or have not
> >studied
> >DIR in any way shape or form, so please, do not think that I am
> >arguing the
> >point, just asking.
> >
> >In talking to others, well versed in technical diving, I have found
> >that you
> >are often put into the same category as Brett Gillam, and Bill Stone.
> >Both of
> >which you don't seem to respect or like. I think this is more to do
> >with your
> >soap box style of preaching of DIR. But from the few conversations I
> >have had
> >with you, and seeing the wealth of knowledge you and the rest of the
> >WKPP
> >have, especially in the cave diving, I find this generalization to be
> >hard to
> >believe.
> >
> >Any answers you are willing to give on any of my statements will be
> >gratefully
> >accepted and welcomed.
> >
> >Alfred
> >
> >kirvine@sa*.ne* wrote:
> >
> >> Michael, you obviously have been misled. Your line of reasoning
> >follows
> >> the Brett Giliam/Bill Stone rationale, a well-documented non
> >sequitur.
> >> If you have a better way of doing things let's hear the logic? If
> >you
> >> think it is a good idea to sit back while well-known and celebrated
> >> divers like Rob Palmer and Rob Parker try to set deep air records or
> >get
> >> killed deep air diving in caves and make up lies and excuses for
> >them,
> >> then join the Gilliam/Stone team - I stand up for what is right
> >while
> >> myself trying to set a good example in diving , depite extreme
> >efforts
> >> by your sources of misinformation to stifle and criticize that.
> >>
> >> Steffie Pamer did not hear of Rob's death from me - she heard it
> >from
> >> the same sources we all did. And by the way, you are just spreading
> >> Gilliam's lies - that makes you just like him. See the article by
> >the
> >> guy who was Rob's dive buddy - Rob was doing exactly what I said he
> >was
> >> doing . That makes him one dumb SOB, and that makes all of his
> >yapping
> >> little stroke buddies, Like Marttyn  Farr and the rest of the big
> >shot
> >> TDI flagellants a pack of fools without the balls to do what is
> >right or
> >> accept the consequences of their actions. By the way, our hamering
> >of
> >> these guys has obviously worked - they changed all of their
> >standards.
> >>
> >> The WKPP always needs money, but your boy Bill Stone did not wnat to
> >buy
> >> his ten scooters from me, he wanted one to copy. It ended up costing
> >him
> >> a lot more than what I offered him, as well as ruin his project.
> >Again,
> >> his fualt, not mine.
> >>
> >> I don't dive electronic rebreathers - I dive mechanical. I have made
> >the
> >> reasons clear. It seems that the track record of electonic
> >rebreathers
> >> speaks for itself, and at Wakulla they were not even able to do what
> >I
> >> did on open circuit, despite the fact that all they had to do is
> >follow
> >> the lines in excellent diving conditions.
> >>
> >> You are spreading more lies about the "cut lines" - maybe you can
> >> document that for us?  The fact is that I am under no obligation to
> >hold
> >> Bill Stone's hand - he said he could do it better than I did it - I
> >said
> >> he could not. I was right.
> >>
> >> When people like you get information from the WKPP, like deco
> >> information, all you want to do is argue with it. We give it to you,
> >you
> >> argue, and then you say you were not given it. I think you will
> >find
> >> that anyhone who wants information from me gets it, and gets it in
> >> person. You are certainly entitled to your opinion, and you are
> >> certainly entitled to not like me or our organization, but lying
> >about
> >> it, making up crap, and using a known quantity like Gilliam or Stone
> >as
> >> your "authoritative source" is not acceptable.
> >>
> >> I do not attend anything that has anything to do with the NSS/CDS ,
> >as
> >> they are in fact the "red necks" you describe, but when you go there
> >you
> >> will have plenty of sympathizers in the cave "community" , but if
> >you
> >> need to be bitch slapped, I am sure we can arrange it, but you will
> >have
> >> to get in line behind several far more deserving big mouths. We just
> >do
> >> not have time for you or your "community". Mikie, the fact is that
> >our
> >> group is a bigger commnunity, and one that is out there doing it
> >while
> >> you and yours are just speculating about it and doing so in a vacuum
> >of
> >> misinformation and self-deluded wallowing stupidity - wake up and
> >smell
> >> the facts, which are that we exist and are open to everyone - we
> >are
> >> where the action is.
> >>
> >
> >
>
> ___________________________________________________________________
> You don't need to buy Internet access to use free Internet e-mail.
> Get completely free e-mail from Juno at http://www.juno.com/getjuno.html
> or call Juno at (800) 654-JUNO [654-5866]

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]