Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

Date: Sun, 17 Sep 1995 01:10:01 -0500
To: techdiver@terra.net
From: mdufour@CA*.OR* (Marc Dufour)
Subject: On the proper use of killfiles and self-healing networks.
Cc: UXMA73A@pr*.co* ( GEORGE M IRVINE III)
        
Now, I've seen it personally.

Never mind that the Internet is a self-healing network that will reroute 
transparently around a malfunctionning node.

Never mind that North America is based on the principle that one knows best 
that is good or bad for one, and one doesn't want anybody else to decide it 
for him.

The malfunctioning node is a censoring node, and to reroute around it, one 
will only have to "post to a different address".

And somebody decided that somebody else was bad for everybody.

If 30% of the people unsubscribed from the list because of someone's 
postings, it shows one thing first and foremost: the 30% of those people 
don't know what a killfile is.

The killfile, gentlemen, allows ONE to decide for HIMSELF whether something 
is good or bad. Period.

This is an open list, if I'm not mistaken. When I joined, nobody asked me 
who I was and if I knew more than a respectable minimum about the 
subject(like the rail signalling list I subscribe to). Then, nobody told me 
that my articles would be scrutinized then approved for posting. 
Furthermore, nobody told me that if I grossly misbehaved, I'd simply be 
locked-out of the list.

I feel cheated.

I feel cheated of obtaining the critical little bit of information I will 
overlook for a totally unthought situation. Information is the name of the 
game, especially in diving, where your ass is on the line, and even more in 
rail signalling where hundreds of asses are on the line.

If one can't cope with the information, no matter how strokish-looking, one 
can shield himself from it, learn to cope with it or flame back. But one 
should not assume that *HE* should shield everyone from it.

That's the whole idea between killfiles.

And the best way of safeguarding free-speech.

Don't ever forget: the anti-Gorbatchev coup was nixed with a lot of help 
from the Internet. It changed the face of the world. It did not change much 
for Tienanmen square, but hopefully, this was for THE LAST time only.

Here, it may only change one ass. Which is definitely not one too much.

Mr. Irvine, forget "UXMA73A@pr*.co*". Be smarter than the list droid, 
route around the defective node, come back in from another door.

----  ====================================================  ----
 I prefer to give a bit of my liberty to an elected government 
         rather than  to  unaccountable corporations.

* Marc Dufour * [\] ACUC 6 31874 * http://WWW.CAM.ORG/~mdufour *

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]