>If the above DIR configuration is correct - is it not possible to have a situation >where you're diving in an overhead environment and the left post gets rolled >off? Yes. That's why, if you do hit the ceiling, you need to check your knobs. >In this event, since there is no depressurization of the reg on the left post the >spg would continue to read a misleadingly high pressure. This strikes me as a <"bad thing". Once more, from the top, here goes: Not a problem. If you check your knobs after any kind of contact, you will never have this issue. The spg being on the left post actually acts as a reminder to check for rolloffs. If for some reason, your spg reads the same thing twice, you need to check the left post a little better. If your left post is indeed open and your spg isn't moving, then check your isolator. If your isolator is open, your spg is stuck. Go home and sort it out to dive another day. If the spg were on the right post, you would have no SECONDARY indication of a rolloff (your primary indication is, once again, checking the knob after any kind of contact) until you tried to breathe the backup. Which would be bad, but better than the alternative of having the long hose on the left post, which creates two possible serious problem scenarios: If you are a "stuffer", and breathe the short hose with the long hose on the left post, you could then inadvertantly pass off a turned off reg to an OOA diver, which would make bad things continue to happen. Expect to be sodomized in the ensuing struggle over the reg in your mouth. If you are a "stuffer" and breathe the long hose off of the left post or simply try to route your long hose from the left post in some bastardization of Doing It Wrong, you will know instantly if your left post rolls off, true enough. However, back to the air sharing scenario: Your buddy is OOA. You pass off your long hose, which is connected to the left post. You were breathing it, so you know it works. All is well. For now. On the way out, you have a left post rolloff. The first person to realize this is your hapless buddy, who is already stressed out, and now OOA for the second time. He now has to signal you and alert you to this problem in order to have air again, OR, more likely, since this would take some contorting and real clear thinking from an already stressed buddy, see the first scenario, and once again, expect to be prison raped in the struggle for your reg. In DIR, your buddy gets the long hose off the right post. The right post rolls on, so he won't be cut off. If you donate your long hose, and you've been neglectful in checking knobs, you will realize this immediately when you try your backup. You, the less stressed of the two parties, can now remedy this immediately by turning on your own left post. On the way out, if your left post rolls off, you will know immediately, and you simply turn it back on, with little stress to you, and none to your buddy, who may very well be making one of those "please god, if you let me get out of this one, I will...." bargains in his head. S/F, Duane -- Send mail for the `techdiver' mailing list to `techdiver@aquanaut.com'. Send subscribe/unsubscribe requests to `techdiver-request@aquanaut.com'.
Navigate by Author:
[Previous]
[Next]
[Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject:
[Previous]
[Next]
[Subject Search Index]
[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]
[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]