Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

Date: Thu, 1 Mar 2001 10:38:32 -0800 (PST)
From: Sea Gypsy <sea_gypsy_nj@ya*.co*>
Subject: Re: NY Cave Fatality
To: Michael Domitrek <n2gypsy@wz*.co*>, techdiver@aquanaut.com
Here are the articles from the local paper:



By ROMA KHANNA and BRUCE A. SCRUTON, Staff writers 
First published: Wednesday, February 28, 2001  
 Diver's body trapped in cave 
New Scotland -- Workers plan to drain pool-sized area
to free student's body

Despite the efforts of nearly a dozen divers, often
using pry bars, the body of an RPI student remained
trapped Tuesday night in Clarksville Cave, and
rescuers now plan to empty the lake so they can chip
his body free. 

Divers dipped into the 40-degree water time and again
Tuesday, trying to free the body of Robert Svensson
from the 18-inch-wide underwater passage where
23-year-old native of Sherborn, Mass., became trapped
Monday evening as he and three others explored the
cave.

About 6:30 p.m. Tuesday, the tired crews of divers
were pulled out of the cave and other workers moved in
to set up pumps, hoping to lower the water level in an
area about the size of a backyard pool so they can
complete their task.

Svensson and his companions, Joseph Baj, 24, of Ozone
Park, Queens, Michael H. Chu, 22, of Niskayuna, and
Jonathan R. Allison, 23, of Troy, entered the cave at
Ward Entrance, just off Route 443, at about 7:30 p.m.
Monday.

The group's destination was the far end of the cave
known as Pauley Avenue, a 180-foot-long, inclined
passage that is filled with water except for the last
2 to 3 feet. The only access is through a hole in the
bottom of the lake in the Lake Room. The nearly
1,000-foot underground route to the Lake Room is a
45-minute trek through narrow passageways and large,
house-sized rooms.

"There are areas that are dry and large enough to
stand up in there,'' said Keith Leonard, captain of
the Onesquethaw Fire Department. "And there are areas
that are under water or where you have to exhale just
to squeeze through.''

As described by Deputy Sheriff John Layton, who has
been to the bottom of the pool and tried to retrieve
the body, once through the seven-foot-long tube where
Svensson's body is trapped, the passage widens out
enough so someone can turn around.

The rest of Pauley Avenue is a 180-foot incline, all
underwater, with nothing at the end. "You have just
enough room to stick your head out of the water, take
a deep breath and go back,'' said Layton, who said he
has never been to the end.

The group apparently found the underwater entranceway
was clogged with silt and other debris. Each tried to
clear the spot. Then Svensson, equipped with a small
air tank and wet suit, plunged into the cold water,
unwilling to accept defeat.

On this last trip, Svensson somehow got wedged in the
seven-foot-long, twisting tunnel. Unable to move
forward or back out, he apparently died when his air
supply ran out.

Layton described that first part of the Pauley Avenue
trip: "Imagine crawling along the foundation wall of a
house, then having to get down into a well and through
the basement window -- all the time having no more
than two feet to work in,'' Layton said.

"We know he's caught at the hips. We don't know about
the shoulders because we can't reach up that far,'' he
continued. In addition to the wet suit, the deputy
said Svensson has a narrow belt around his hips.

Svensson was using a "pony bottle'' -- a small air
tank about the size of a fire extinguisher -- for his
air supply. During their initial rescue efforts, his
friends attempted to pass him additional air before
calling for help.

The divers brought in for the recovery worked until
early Tuesday morning, when they were brought out of
the cave about 1:30 a.m. They returned later in the
morning, trying and reviving plans as each effort
proved ineffective.

The "lake'' in the Lake Room is about 7-to-9-feet deep
and about 15-to-20-feet across. With all that water,
the recovery crew is, in effect, trying to empty a
backyard swimming pool while, at the same time,
several garden hoses are trying to fill it up at about
50 gallons per minute.

"It looks like we'll have to use two pumps,'' said
Adam Hornick of the Onesquethaw Fire Department. "One,
we're hoping, will even off what's flowing in, and the
other will be emptying.''

To do the pump-out, the crews are using a natural
opening from outside to the Lake Room about 25 feet up
in the ceiling. Just after dark and after divers had
made a last attempt to free the body, a crew was
working to enlarge the opening, which has filled in
over the years.

Special hydraulic pumps will then be lowered to the
shoreline of the underground lake. The drain lines
will be going straight up, at least 25 feet, explained
Hornick, which will cut the efficiency of the pumps.
Also, because the lake is underground, there is
increased air pressure, which also reduces the pump
outflow.

Once the lake level is reduced, workers can get to the
opening to Pauley Avenue and chip away at the rock and
slate walls where Svensson was trapped.

Svensson was an experienced outdoorsman whose
activities included rock climbing and skiing, but was
not a certified diver, according to Brian Chouiniere,
who teaches diving courses at RPI. Svensson had
completed an open-water diving course taught by
Chouiniere in December but had not yet completed the
final elements of the course that would have given him
open-water certification.

"He had some experience with open-water diving but he
was in no way qualified to dive in a cave,''
Chouiniere said.

At least two of Svensson's companions, Baj and
Allison, had completed open-water diving courses with
Chouiniere.

Friends and family of Svensson kept a tearful vigil
near the scene. As they awaited word of the recovery,
the group consoled each other and walked along the
country road near the cave to pass the time.

Meghan Lord, a friend of Svensson's, arrived at the
scene before 9 a.m., shortly after her father found
out about the incident from the morning news, because
she wanted to be sure someone was on hand when his
body was recovered. Lord said Svensson, who taught
undergraduates and wanted to be a professor, had a
great interest in caving and spent a lot of time
exploring and mapping caves around the area.

"This was not just an extreme sport to him,'' she
said. "He took it seriously.''

Local residents believe this may be the first fatality
in at least a half century at the cave, a popular
attraction for cavers from around the region. The cave
is also used for training the Albany County Sheriff's
Department.

"People are in this cave 24 hours a day, seven days a
week,'' said Leonard, who lives across the street from
the main entrance. "No matter what time I come home, I
see lights around it. I see charter buses and cars
with license plates from Tennessee to Vermont up
here.'' 
 


By BRUCE A. SCRUTON, Staff writer 
First published: Thursday, March 1, 2001  
 Diver's body pulled from cave 
New Scotland -- Rescuers pump water from underground
lake to extract student stuck in crevice

With just a handful of minutes to spare, a sheriff's
deputy wiggled feet first into the underwater tunnel
that had trapped and killed Robert Svensson and
finally managed to free the body of the RPI student
Wednesday night after days of trying.

"The way the water was rising, we had maybe five, 10
minutes to get him out,'' said Albany County Chief
Deputy Craig Apple. "After that, it would have been
wait until tomorrow.'' 

A nearly daylong effort to pump water from the small
underground lake in the Clarksville Cave had exposed
the end of the tunnel where Svensson, a 23-year-old
from Sherborn, Mass., had become trapped Monday
evening while on an outing with three fellow RPI
students. But one of the pumps suddenly failed,
allowing water back into the area and jeopardizing
recovery efforts.

Svensson apparently died when he became trapped and
the air supply he was carrying for his underwater
expedition ran out. His friends made initial rescue
efforts and, when those failed, made the 1,000-foot
journey to the cave's entrance and called for help.
Divers worked several hours Monday night into Tuesday
morning, trying to free the body. A full day of work
Tuesday also proved fruitless, and the decision was
made to pump out the lake.

The two pumps lowered through a hole in the ceiling of
the Lake Room worked throughout the day Wednesday and,
by about 6 p.m., had dropped the level of the lake to
below the entrance of the tunnel.

That's when one of the pumps failed.

"The second pump was able to keep up with the
inflow,'' Apple said, "so we decided to try to get the
body out.''

Because they were working underwater, the earlier
efforts had failed because the divers were unable to
get any leverage. The water was also nearly black with
silt, eliminating visibility, so work was by feel.

With the water gone, Svensson's feet were clearly
visible at the opening of the tunnel, which leads to
an area of the cave known as Pauley Avenue.

However, in front of the entrance was a thick covering
of muck and dirt. Standing on that slippery surface,
the deputies still could not get the leverage needed
to move the body.

A team of diggers climbed down and within 20 minutes
loaded 50 or more five-gallon pails of muck and
removed sizable rocks to give solid footing.

"It's was a nasty scene (at the bottom of the lake).
Very mucky, very dirty. A lot of rocks,'' Apple said.

And, while the diggers were clearing the spot, the
second pump gave out.

With Undersheriff John R. Mahan keeping an eye on the
water level, which he said was rising rather quickly
as the lake refilled, Apple and Investigator William
Riley moved to the entrance.

While the deputies were not in any danger, Apple said
that had the water risen to cover the tunnel entrance,
the recovery efforts would have had to be put off for
a day until the pumps could be repaired or replaced.

"That would have been too much,'' Mahan said.
"Emotionally, for the family and the recovery people,
we wanted to get him out.''

Earlier in the day, as the water level was receding,
Albany County Sheriff James L. Campbell expressed
similar concerns.

"There is a sense of tension with the family members.
This is the third day and they want closure,'' he
said. After the recovery, the sheriff reiterated:
"This is a great relief, for the family, for everybody
involved.''

Apple, wearing a "Gumby'' suit, a special set of
shoulder-high waders designed as a flotation device,
wriggled feet-first into the tunnel. "There was still
water in there. It goes straight down,'' he said, and
Svensson was in a head-down position in the tunnel.

Squeezing his feet past Svensson's hips and down into
the water, Apple was able to use them to partially
straighten Svensson's body. Then, with his hands and
Riley's help outside the tube, they moved the body
back and forth, turning it at the same time.

"It was like a corkscrew maneuver. Once we could get
his hips turned, he came right out,'' Apple said.

From the position of the body, investigators surmise
that Svensson "looks like he got part-way in, then
decided to get out. Instead of backing out, he
apparently tried to turn around and that's when he got
stuck,'' Apple said. He said the body was in a sitting
position with the hips filling the tunnel from top to
bottom, leaving just enough room to the back for Apple
to get his legs past.

Over the winter, debris had apparently closed down the
opposite end of the tunnel, and it was those rocks and
dirt that the four college students were trying to
clear away Monday.

Svensson told his friends, Joseph Baj, 24, of Ozone
Park, Queens; Michael H. Chu, 22, of Niskayuna; and
Jonathan R. Allison, 23, of Troy; that he would make
one final dive to clear more debris.

Apple said the tunnel has been used before because
there was a tag line leading through the tunnel. The
line, or rope, is left by previous divers to provide a
guide. Using the line to pull oneself along, an
explorer can quickly get through a tight spot.

The chief deputy said the tag line was looped around
Svensson's arm, but he doesn't know if it was done
during the dive or by recovery efforts. Svensson was
still wearing the mask connected to the air bottle
strapped to his leg.

The body was brought out of the cave complex about
7:30 p.m. and taken to Albany Medical Center Hospital
where an autopsy is to be performed.

At RPI Wednesday night, the Outing Club met at its
usual time. More than two dozen students showed up,
many discussing the accident before the meeting began,
others wearing the club's traditional red button-down
shirt. The meeting was closed to the media.

writers Roma Khanna and Alan Wechsler contributed to
this story. 

 

--- Michael Domitrek <n2gypsy@wz*.co*> wrote:
> Anyone have any information on this, spotted a small
> article in the local paper. Article stated it was at
> Clarksville, NY cave and that as of Tuesday they
> could not recover the body........  Michael
> 


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Get email at your own domain with Yahoo! Mail. 
http://personal.mail.yahoo.com/
--
Send mail for the `techdiver' mailing list to `techdiver@aquanaut.com'.
Send subscribe/unsubscribe requests to `techdiver-request@aquanaut.com'.

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]