Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

From: <kirvine@sa*.ne*>
Date: Mon, 13 Dec 1999 10:42:57 -0500
To: John Walker <techdive@ea*.ne*>
CC: techdiver@aquanaut.com
Subject: Re: My Dive this weekend an "Air" thing
John, it is hard to believe but it explains a lot that happens later on
in diving. NAUI calls it "primacy" - you believe what you learn first,
and it sounds like they are sending the worng message right from the get
go.

John Walker wrote:
> 
>    I concur with you George.  Its unfortunate that the industry breeds
> divers this way, IGNORANT.  And it's a shame that green divers are easily
> given a credential to teach diving with the same IGNORANCE that was taught
> to them.
> 
>    Early last week I was invited to give a presentation to a group of NAUI
> O/W instructor candidates.  Not realizing what lay ahead, I agreed to do so
> on the spur of the moment.  The course director had never approved of the
> diving that I did, but I felt that she was truly interested in my sharing
> something about technical diving. Man, was I wrong.
> 
>    I got to a point in the presentation where I shared with the group how
> several techniques used in technical diving have became adaptable to
> recreational diving to enhance safety.  I explained how donating the reg
> from the mouth of the donor to an out of air diver made a hell of a lot more
> sense than teaching divers to give a silly ass signal and wait for the doner
> to find the octopus attached to some off the wall location on his/her BCD
> while the OOA diver starts to drown.
> 
>    The course director went off on me in attempt to make me look like the
> stupid one. The funny thing is, it backfired on her.  She looked like the
> stupid one.  She told me (and the instructor candidates) that if we taught
> this technique that 50% of her students would drowned.  If so, those 50% of
> divers should never recieve a C-card.  Don't we also teach to never dive
> beyond our limits and beyond what we are taught?  These divers should then
> never be placed in a situation were this could happen, they should never be
> placed in the water.  She also said, "Screw the out of air diver, I'm not
> the one who ran out of air.  It's their problem."  But at the same time she
> pretends to promote the buddy system.
> 
>    I was flabbergasted that she was actually training INSTRUCTORS, who will
> someday be responsible for taking the general public into a hazardous
> invironment, with this sort of philosophy.  It amazed me that she would
> consider certifying a diver who could not survive if their own reg was
> pulled from their mouth, but yet she teaches two different reg retrievals in
> the water. Go figure!
> 
>    This is beyond sad.  The breeding of this nonsense is progressing beyond
> belief.  Something needs to be done.  People need to know the truth in order
> to survive underwater, and they need to be taught realistic survival skills.
> Dive training has to be focused on REAL LIFE diving, not fabricated
> bullshit. Instructors resorting to this rediculous bullshit rather than REAL
> LIFE diving needs should get a clue that THEY SHOULD NOT BE TEACHING DIVING.
> 
>       John
> 
>  >We have a serious problem in the dive training industry and in "tech"
> > diving with the ignorance and moronity of the big mouths who have never
> > "been there done that" except in their own minds in the most pathetic
> > little weenie bounce diving do nothing way - none of these guys have
> > been "Downtown" or played hardball and as such have no idea what the
> > real story is. These people are influencing diving and that is why we
> > have so many "unexplained" accidents.
> >
> >  It behooves all of us in the WKPP and anyone else with a brain on their
> > shoulders to get out there and counter the Pete hess's and other
> > horrendous ignoramuses in diving in and out of the "training" agencies .
> > We owe it to everyone to do this, since we have the real experience and
> > know for certain what the problems are and can see why the deaths are
> > stacking up.
> >
> >  We are doing things underwater for years with a perfrect track record
> > that none of these big mouths has ever or will ever do, and we need to
> > have the confindence to point that out to everyone and to take the abuse
> > from the Big Vons and other lowlifes and keep telling the story and keep
> > refering to what we really do and what our scorecard looks like, and
> > save some lives in the process.
> >
> >  You have all seen the extreme measure that some of the training agency
> > jerks have gone to in order to try to discredit me and the WKPP, and you
> > constantly see the viciousness of the attacks out of the
> > representatives of these agencies and the deep air or bullshit equipment
> > crowd. We are blowing the whistle on all of them, and that is why. We
> > need to have the same tanacity that they do .
> >
> >  There is no reason to ever be polite to a dangerous idiot, and there is
> > no reason not to step all over them with the facts every last time they
> > stick their heads up, I would appreciate it if more of our members would
> > take the time to teach other people the truth, and to kick some of these
> > strokes right in the ass publicly whenever you can with extreme
> > prejudice.
> >
> > --
> > Send mail for the `techdiver' mailing list to `techdiver@aquanaut.com'.
> > Send subscribe/unsubscribe requests to `techdiver-request@aquanaut.com'.
> >


--
Send mail for the `techdiver' mailing list to `techdiver@aquanaut.com'.
Send subscribe/unsubscribe requests to `techdiver-request@aquanaut.com'.

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]