Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

To: "Richard Pyle" <Richard_Pyle@qm*.sp*.tr*.co*>
Subject: Re: IWR
From: "Steve Hogan" <Steve_Hogan@qm*.sp*.tr*.co*>
Cc: "techdiver" <techdiver@opal.com>
Date: 8 Dec 1994 15:02:15 -0800
 Reply to:     RE>>IWR

Rich Pyle writes:
<snip disclaimer>

>It is well established, even by supporters of the practice of IWR, that
>there are many theoretical disadvantages to attempting IWR if only air is
>available as a breathing gas.  Nevertheless, after researching the topic
>rather extensively, and in consideration of my own personal observations
>and experiences, these theoretical disadvantages are not substantiated by
>reality in the vast majority of cases.  If I were much more than 30 minutes
>away from a chamber, and I began to experience potentially serious
>neurological DCI symptoms, and no oxygen was available (but air was), I
>probably wouldn't hesitate to jump back in the water. (Bear in mind that I
>NEVER intend to be in such a situation, as I almost always have Plenty of
>oxygen around when I conduct even remotely hazardous dives).

>I still maintain that I am not especially "pro-IWR". The decision to
>attempt IWR depends on MANY factors, and I submit that there are very few
>broad generalizations that can be made about the topic.


>Now THAT oughtta stir things up a bit!

This looks like a DELIBERATE PLOT to change the techdiver subject ;-)

>I'm wearing my asbestos suit, so fire away..

Sorry Rich, no flame as I agree with you. I would also NEVER intend to be in
such a situation but if I felt symptoms coming on and the chamber is more than
1-2 hours away (depending on my condition) I would *probably* opt for 
IWR also. My opinion is that it is better to get back under pressure as soon
as possible than wait for the chamber.

Steve Hogan
Steve_Hogan@qm*.sp*.tr*.co*

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]