Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

To: "INTERNET:shelps@ac*.ma*.ad*.ed*.au*" <shelps@ac*.ma*.ad*.ed*.au*>
Subject: Re: DCI Survey
From: Richard Taylor <100237.2220@co*.co*>
Cc: techdiver <techdiver@opal.com>
Date: 01 Dec 94 03:33:29 EST
>>Well, at the risk of labouring the point, and to make any survey usefull 
>>(and I think an anonymous survey might be usefull), what do you define as 
a 
>>DCI 'hit'?  All symptoms ranging from a bit of tingling in the left 
armpit 
>>to full blown fulminant cerebral DCI producing death?
>
>for my excercise I would say let the user decide.  If someone has DCI & 
>denies it the only way I will be informed is if
>1. the patient was treated
>2. the victim could not deny it but still did not seek treatment.

>If you don't have uniform criteria for deciding who is bent, or by how 
much 
t>hey are bent, the survey will be of no value whatsover.>>Well, at the 
risk of labouring the point, and to make any survey usefull 
>>(and I think an anonymous survey might be usefull), what do you define as 
a 
>>DCI 'hit'?  All symptoms ranging from a bit of tingling in the left 
armpit 
>>to full blown fulminant cerebral DCI producing death?
>
>for my excercise I would say let the user decide.  If someone has DCI & 
>denies it the only way I will be informed is if
>1. the patient was treated
>2. the victim could not deny it but still did not seek treatment.
>
>If you don't have uniform criteria for deciding who is bent, or by how 
much 
>they are bent, the survey will be of no value whatsover.
>
>/rat

But how do you determine "how much" a person is bent?  If they denied it to 
themselves will they admit it now?  If so how valid is that?

What about this criteria:

A pain or accepted sympton experienced after a dive not explained by a pre 
existing symptom.  Denial would therefore be "I am not bent but feel a 
symptom".

Regards

Richard T
----------------------------
Diver: Do Not Bend
-----------------------------   


/rat

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]