Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

Date: Fri, 04 Sep 1998 09:58:41 -0400
From: Wrolf Courtney <wrolf@co*.ne*>
To: Kevin Rottner <Kevin@So*.co*>
CC: techdiver@aquanaut.com, Martin Parker <mjp@ap*.av*.co*.uk*>
Subject: Re: Call to Arms, Part 2
I assume that you are not referring to the Buddy Inspiration incidents.  (See
http://www.concentric.net/~Wrolf/index.shtml#Inspiration.)

If you are, and if in fact stepped up training is the key, then A.P. Valves is
to
praised, not pilloried.

I understand the hurt that a survivor would feel, but A.P. Valves did not as I
understand set the training schedule - that was the agencies.  Now they have
decided
to go beyond what the agencies say is the minimum required, and offer factory
top up
training, in a best guess hope that this will solve the problem.

At their own cost.

Anyway, I know that Martin Parker wouldn't sue you.  Or even me for that
matter, and
he might have had cause when I published before hearing the other side.  You
cannot be
talking about them.  Most Brits regard the American legal system as looney (I
am a
British ex-pat, naturalized American - it is looney), and the last thing they
would do
is get involved in it if they could avoid it.

If you have information about the Atlantis incidents, or updated information on
the
Buddy Inspiration incidents, I would be very grateful.

Wrolf

Kevin Rottner wrote:

> Manufacturers.
>
> You all love to argue about bondage wings and other equipment that MAY
> contribute to incidents or accidents, or if you should breath off the short
> hose or the long hose ( the whole DIR war , etc. etc.)  Well, what the hell
> are we all going to do about death gear. Shit that you now is killing
> people. DEATH GEAR, ya thats what it is. That's what I called the Fieno
> Grand Bleu 'breather that I saw at DEMA a few years back. Right to the
> manufacturor's face. THIS IS DEATH GEAR YOU FOOLS ! YOU ARE GOING TO KILL
> INNOCENT PEOPLE, I said. Two people in a near by booth bought me a beer when
> they overheard me.
>
> Keep on getting those e-mails from the survivors of SCUBA fatalities. Here's
> another one, this time seems a certain not-to-be-mentioned rebreather
> manufacturor has their own growing body count. What are we gonna do ?? Let's
> just say this poor woman's letter " inspired " me to post. Get it ?
>
> I did some editing to protect the person I am corresponding with, but you
> will get the general idea.
>
> _______________________________________________________
>
> Hi,
>         ****** ******* died in ( Month ) of (this or very recent ) year, the
first
> of the ( 'breather manufacturor ) fatalities, trusting his ( brand name )
> rebreather and the training he had received for using it. I am ******
> *******, ****** *******'s ( close relative ). ****** ******* died beleiving
> what he was taught, believing what he did was safe, so why should I  need to
> counter the lies spread about him by the equipment manufacturers. ******
> ******* had not been diving for a great length of time, but within that time
> he dived as freequrently as the (foreign country ) weather permitted, and
> did his utmost to become as educated  and familiar as possible with his
> practices. ****** ******* purchased his rebreather with the intention of
> making his trimix diving safer (less chance of running out of air if
> entanglemint should occur, etc), not to extend bottom times by a huge amount
> or take any risks, but to improve the safety of his beloved hobby. ******
> ******* was a good man, probably the truest person I will ever know, he
> would help anyone, and his helping with the progression of the inspiration
> gave him great pride, with the thought that his efforts would be helping
> others. Now he is not here to defend himself, certain people are accusing
> him of being some sort of idiot. He did nothing without first consulting the
> manufacturers of (type of 'breather ) or an instuctor. He was a very
> intelligent man. I am only an open water diver, but it is amazing how much
> you can learn about rebreathers in a very short time.
>
>         What a political world we live in. He was told everything he was
doing was
> fine, now they decide you need 150 hours of rebreather experience before
> taking a mix dive. How they have changed their tune to what Paul and the
> other early ones were told. ****** ******* was the only fatality using
> trimix, the others were at shallow depths and using air, and unfortunately
> for us who want to improve safety, their units were not recovered. In one
> case the diver has not yet been recovered either. Therefore the
> manufacturers are saying that ****** ******* died because he was using
> trimix, and probably hope that the other units will not be recovered. ******
> ******* did not cause his own death. He died because he believed what he was
> doing was safe in the same way as others have lost their lives because of
> what they have been lead to believe.
>
> ( last para deleted )
>
> ( name deleted ).
>
> ______________________________________________________________
>
> Since my Call to Arms post, I have been threatened with lawsuits, and had
> attorney's tell me that I am stepping into the land of libel, slander and
> defamation. ( wasn't on in my map, but I knew it existed somewhere. )
>
> So I am trying not to name names, you know.
>
> And yes, I realize that decedant was:
>
> Qualified for Trimix, but I don't know if in a 'breather.
>
> This was a third replacement unit, current unit decedant was using had been
> repaired for oxygen spiking.
>
> Subject was solo.
>
> PM indictated no physical problems.
>
> Subject was found in a state that might suggest hypoxia.
>
> C'mon, you all know its a deat unit.
>
> DEATH GEAR.
>
> So what are we gonna do ??
>
> Kevin



--
Wrolf

Wrolf's Wreck:     http://www.concentric.net/~Wrolf
Wrolf's Net.Wreck: http://www.concentric.net/~Wrolf/netmgmt.shtml


--
Send mail for the `techdiver' mailing list to `techdiver@aquanaut.com'.
Send subscribe/unsubscribe requests to `techdiver-request@aquanaut.com'.

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]