Mailing List Archive Mailing List Archive
Jeremey, I've been here for years on cavers and techdiver, yet I'm relatively new to the rebreather list. That being said, I am probably older (52) than your Buddy pH, and have possibly been diving longer, but that's another point and beside the question. All I hear from Dr. pH(art),as you call him, is lots of noise (ha, a pun) with apparently little visible substance in terms of experience, at least relative to his current opponent. Most of us know George's accomplishments and find them exceptional, we know he and the WKPP does the dives and the deco and survives without being hammered (most likely a function of conditioning). I also find their view on CCR's and electronics also carries lots of intuitive appeal. The point is we know the WKPP does the dives and the deco, the question is what are the good Doctor's qualifications to argue with one, or a group, who have been doing the dives successfully for some time? If pH has the experience people will listen to him, if not, then he is simply full of crap and pontificating theory rather than practice. I am merely trying to find a basis as to why one would accept the views of pH unless he actually has the experience and qualifications to argue with what is becoming proven fact.I have seen his posts on the rebreather list, but does he have anywhere near the experience of the WKPP divers with extreme dives? I tend to believe he doesn't... In all seriousness, I am really interested in pH's qualifications in this arena. by the way, rhyme is the correct spelling of "rhime". Looking forward to your response... Jeremy Downs wrote: > > pH new to these lists??......... Now there is a funny line! There is more > than one reason he's referred to as the old pHart. ;^) > > Obviously your the one who is new, now only if you had a clue! > (hey, that rhimes!) > > (please don't CC me to cavers, that list is a royal pain in the ass as it > seems a complete imbicile is maintianing it) > > At 07:27 PM 8/3/98 -0400, Peter Wallace wrote: > >Dr. H, here's an interesting point: > > > >Since you are apparently relatively new to the cavers list and > >techdiver, and after reading your posts and following your on-going > >exchange with kirvine and Bill Mee, I for one would like to know > >something of your diving qualifications. > > > > -- Send mail for the `techdiver' mailing list to `techdiver@aquanaut.com'. Send subscribe/unsubscribe requests to `techdiver-request@aquanaut.com'.
Navigate by Author:
[Previous]
[Next]
[Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject:
[Previous]
[Next]
[Subject Search Index]
[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]
[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]