Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

To: techdiver@opal.com
Subject: portmanteau messages; replying in long messages
From: "A.APPLEYARD" <A.APPLEYARD@fs*.mt*.um*.ac*.uk*>
Date: Mon, 8 Aug 1994 08:39:08 GMT
  I am very sorry to `play at being a moderator', but please!!:-
  On Fri 5 Aug a long message "Subject: Bent fish, terrorist dolphins & human
evolution..." went to Techdiver which had successive long sections about 3
different subjects:-

  (1) Fish suffering from decompression sickness.
  (2) Dolphins trained to attack scuba divers.
  (3) Miskito Indian scuba divers suffering from decompression sickness.

  Putting several different subjects into the same message makes life
difficult for readers who (like me) keep separate email folders for the
various aspects of diving that get discussed on techdiver and elsewhere. This
message wants to go in two places (or in 3, if the mention of anti-diver
dolphins encourages a rush of email which will need a new separate folder).
Thus I will have to keep 3 copies of it, filling out my email store allowance.
Then I may have to save store space by separating the subjects by removing
each subject from all but one of the copies, by the risky process of direct
surgery with a text editor on the email system's folder files. Luckily my
emailer has a `PREBUILD' command to tell it to rebuild one of its folder's
index files after accidental or deliberate damage to it or to its folder.
  I feel that this message's author should have sent it out as 3 separate
messages, each about one of the abovementioned subjects.
  --------------------------------------------
  Next day a reader replied (Subject: decompression luck or evolution (was:
Bent fish, terrorist dolphins & human evolution...), quoting its long "bent
Miskito Indians" section in full, adding to emailer store usage. When replying
to a long message which all your readers will have new copies of already, why
not edit the quoted matter down to the minimum needed for the reader to tell
what part of it is being replied to, representing deleted matter by `...'?

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]