Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

Date: Fri, 1 Mar 1996 16:47:56 -0500
To: cherf@ci*.co* (Scott Cherf)
From: m.therrien@ne*.qc*.ca* (Michel Therrien)
Subject: Cochran computers (was Nemesis Nitrox 11)
Cc: techdiver@terra.net

>I had this happen to me last December, and yes it is true.  I had a valve
>down on my primary reg at 80 feet while begining decompression at the end
>of a 60 minute dive.  When my reg started to shut down I grabbed one of
>my partner's backups (air) and we began our ascent.  My computer switched
>to 100% O2 decompression and I didn't notice until we hit our 30' stop
>(which is when I got my valve turned back on and switched to my own
>main supply).  At 20' I went on O2, but the computer had already cleared
>me for a direct ascent.

...

>I think it's a darned good reason to plan and execute your
>dive on tables.  I use my computer as a backup in emergencies (i.e. unplanned
>excursions beyond the calculated decompression profiles).
>
>BTW, I have several dives on this machine and like it *very* much.  I would
>no longer consider making a technical dive without it.


First, thanks for commenting my message.

Now, serious stuff: Your conclusion seems to be irrational... you just
confirmed earlier that the unit is badly designed and is not reliable and
your saying that you would not consider making a technical dive without it. 

My opinion is that for technical dives, we must use equipment that we are
pretty sure will not fail during the dive.  In the case of that device, it
seems to be obvious that it may fail, most certainly if you have another
problem (like the one you mentioned).

I do not own a Nemesis computer, but I made dives with computers of that
company.  One was not functioning in cold water (it was a Sherwood Sentry
made by Cochran).  I learned later that it was because of the cold water
feature of the computer (should I say that the software to disable it was
not available).  The other one, a Beuchat Maestro Pro (manufactured by
Cochran Consulting) was still 10-15 feet off even after being returned
several times to the supplier.  Finally, the problem was corrected, but I
was not able to witness it since the computer did not turn on until the end
of my dive!  One of my friends confirmed that the depth was reading OK on a
later dive.

The design of the gas switch feature seems to be completely erroneous... I
would not trust that for any of my dives.

On the positive side, the Maestro Pro screen layout is fantastic... when its
working.  The case and the wrist strap seems to be rugged enough.  I also
like the blue color around the screen '-).

Michel Therrien
m.therrien@ne*.qc*.ca*

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]