Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

Date: Mon, 26 Oct 1998 13:37:22 -0500
To: "Hydra Explorations Inc." <hydra@hy*.co*>
From: Skip MacElhannon <skipmac@cs*.co*>
Subject: Re: Dumb and Getting Dumber
Cc: techdiver@aquanaut.com
You state that on your dives from the Grateful Diver "Maximum depth=
 limitations and gas requirements were regulated by TDI and IANTD's=
 standards and procedures, as well as the operational standards for the=
 Grateful Diver."  For clarification, what mix was used and to what depth=
 were your dives?

Also, according to your own web page you offer TDI instructions on air to=
 200' and IANTD classes for Advanced Deep Air.  I assume that you are aware=
 that there has been some concern recently about tbe safety of deep air=
 diving, regardless of the standards at TDI and IANTD.  Do you still teach=
 and promote these courses or do you feel that diving deep on air is safe=
 for those who are acclimated?

Finally, you give your equipment configuration as dry suit and steel back=
 tanks.  What was the configuration of the other divers (students) on the=
 dive?  Were they diving wet suits and steel tanks?

At 10:35 AM 10/26/98 -0500, you wrote:
>Possible title for your article - "Misinformed, and Getting More=
 Misinformed"
>
>
>
>So my phone begins to ring=85my e-mail becomes congested, and fellow divers=
 are muttering phrases like "dousing themselves with urine", and "charging=
 unrelentingly into the enemy machine guns", and "license to kill".  My=
 associates were calling, wanting to know if I had seen an article about me,=
 which was posted at TechDiver.  (I commend Techdiver for their=
 establishment of an outstanding communications network throughout the=
 technical communities!)
>
>To address this recent posting, "Dumb and Getting Dumber", by Mr. Bill Mee,=
 posted on Thursday, October 22, I provide the following information:
>
>Dear Mr. Mee:
>
>The course I solicited the Grateful Diver to run was not a "Deep Air"=
 class; rather an Advanced/EANx Wreck Diver course.  Maximum depth=
 limitations and gas requirements were regulated by TDI and IANTD's=
 standards and procedures, as well as the operational standards for the=
 Grateful Diver.=20
>
>Background on equipment for that particular dive:  I dove OMS 108's with an=
 isolation manifold. For the BC, I dove an OMS double bladder single bag=
 with 100 lbs. of buoyancy.  I used a signature series CF-300 DUI dry suit=
 with SI-5 wrist rings (which allows for in-the-field replacement in minutes=
 for either gloves or wrist seals).
>
>The second stage from which I breathe is a 9-ft. hose, secured vertically=
 to the right side of my backplate; it can be deployed quickly and easily. =
 My DiveRite Neutralite 12 is a few years old, but has performed=
 excellently, and I'm very comfortable with its butt mount.
>
>The manufacturer's silicon tubing on my wings has never failed to allow=
 adequate buoyancy with my steel OMS stage bottles.  Mr. Mee, with your=
 relationship with another manufacturer of BC's and dive equipment, I=
 understand how you may be opposed to the designs of OMS, DiveRite, Scuba=
 Pro and others who use "bungee wings".  I am pleased, however, to know that=
 you are as happy with your wings as I am with mine.
>
>As far as improperly marked gas: it was suggested to me that I use large=
 strips of duct tape down the length of my stages with the maximum operating=
 depth listed thereon in large numbers.  I am always looking for and=
 evolving to accommodate better ideas.  I know there is no absolute "right"=
 way for every diver.  (If you think there is, let's review "soldiers of=
 strokism".)  I like this particular idea, and will include it in my=
 instruction programs, as well as my normal practice of labeling the=
 percentage of the mixture and complying with all other training agencies'=
 requirements.  I already advocate the use of oxygen bags/mouth blocks,=
 second stages identifiable by touch and sight, as well as bottle placement=
 for gas recognition.
>
>As for being especially cautious due to the recent four diving fatalities=
 in 1998, I believe every high-risk dive must be conducted with special=
 caution.  Apart from being cautious, there is being honest with oneself=
 about one's diving abilities, and not allowing a lot of egotism to infect=
 perception; thus, one must also look towards physical conditioning. (But=
 everyone reading this article knows there's no egotism around here!) =
 Physical conditioning is a daily requirement, and a way of life.  My=
 recommendation is for many divers to begin here.
>
>Regarding the boat captain: as always, I keep a high standard when=
 conducting my courses.  Therefore I solicited the Grateful Diver.  The=
 "willing" boat captain did a nice job, and the boat ran well.  The three=
 days of diving Trimix (which is the boat's requirement, and my gas of=
 choice - not air) on the Lowrance and the R.B. Johnson were=
 enjoyable...although I was unaware that the service included the=
 publication of ill-informed, negative articles afterwards. =20
>
>As for my "unwitting students", their credentials upon arriving on my=
 doorstep were:
>
>First candidate: Respiratory medical physician, PADI Open Water Instructor,=
 Advanced EANx Instructor, Full-Cave and Trimix Diver, among others.
>
>Second candidate:  Professional in aero-engineering, also a PADI Open Water=
 Instructor, Advanced EANx Instructor, Full-Cave and Trimix Diver, among=
 others.
>
>Both of these candidates lived up to expectations, and have moved on to=
 continue their education at NOAA.  The good doctor will proceed for further=
 training at NASA upon approval of his final preselected application.
>
>Next in line is my "license to kill".    How about license to educate? =20
>
>I have been diving for over eighteen years, and am president and owner of=
 Hydra Explorations, Inc.  The central focus of this organization is safe=
 diving instruction up to and beyond 130 ft. on various mixtures of gas.   =
 In 1991 I earned EANx Instructor #76 by IAND.  I am an Instructor Trainer=
 and a Technical Instructor for IANTD and TDI, and am NSSCDS/IANTD Full-Cave=
 Certified.  In addition to my certification as Master Instructor with PADI,=
 I have taught eleven specialties, as well as Medic First Aid/CPR. I have=
 also earned recognition as an instructor with ANDI and DAN, and am trained=
 in the latest knowledge of gas separation and mixing systems.  I am=
 certified to 100-tons as a U.S. Coast Guard Captain, with endorsement.  I=
 have taught EANx and EANx Instructor courses at Aqua Corps' Tek, presented=
 lectures and taught at world trade shows such as DEMA, and at major trade=
 shows such as the Boston Sea Rovers and Ocean Expo.  I implement state of=
 the art technologies, such as mixed-gas rebreathers, as part of !
>Hydra's training services.
>
>Mr. Mee, I hope this clarifies for you the events as they actually=
 occurred.  Your rebuke was based on inaccurate information, and perhaps=
 given a little hastily for that.  But I would like to thank you, and all=
 those working with you, for your efforts in furthering this small yet=
 growing industry.  God bless you for your concern for our lives.
>
>If anyone has any other comments, questions on this article or any courses=
 offered by Hyrda Explorations, please visit my web site at:=
 http://www.hydraexplorations.com
>
>--
>Send mail for the `techdiver' mailing list to `techdiver@aquanaut.com'.
>Send subscribe/unsubscribe requests to `techdiver-request@aquanaut.com'.
>=20


--
Send mail for the `techdiver' mailing list to `techdiver@aquanaut.com'.
Send subscribe/unsubscribe requests to `techdiver-request@aquanaut.com'.

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]