Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

Date: Wed, 21 Jan 1998 12:32:38 -0800
From: Alex Towns <Alex.Towns@sy*.bt*.co*.uk*>
Organization: Syntegra
To: techdiver@aquanaut.com
Subject: Re: Lift Bags vs. DSMBs
John

> >I like the idea of all divers being on a blob, but you have to take
> >great care not to get tangled in each others line while hanging,
> >otherwise you end up with an u/w May Pole (translated - a strange
> >English dance of chasing each other around a pole holding a bit of rope
> >attached at the top - normally involves lots of bells & strange
> >clothing, but I digress!!!)

> As the guy says, "Do it right" with the right system and there is no
> problem.

Hmmm - so what IS the right system? We use a trapeze that remains on the shot
till all
the markers have been removed or after a preset time, when it is then cast
adrift and
all float with the trapeze. Spare gas is at 9m & another tank is rigged & ready
to go
on the boat in case a signal buoy is sent up!

The DSMB is now very much the reserve system - yes we used to use it
exclusively with
the rec diving and to start with when doing these dives & found their
disadvantages
through experience. If you need to resort to the DSMB on a long hang then I
prefer all
to deploy DSMB but keeping in close proximity with your buddy does increase the
risk of
the lines tangling up - especially on the deep stops when the viz brings the
pair
closer together. Sometimes the lines do get tangled - then it becomes a pain as
you
find the pair are continually swinging together. Worth pointing out as it can &
does
happen - not a catastropy but the more people are aware the better IMO! If you
need to
resort to a DSMB then much better for 'one diver, one DSMB on the surface' as a
rule.



> I have the odd combination of being a gas diver instructor and a
> Skipper. what is often not realised by the diver is that any system
> involving a boat should do exactly that. Too many ideas are hatched by
> divers for divers and do not take into consideration the boat and how it
> handles etc etc.

I agree with you here - the team consists of the divers the skipper & the boat
- all
rely on each other for a safe trip.

> Just one example is how a skipper is often expected to
> administer o2 when his responsibility is to inform emergency services
> etc and collect other divers and get the boat ashore or too a rendezvous
> point etc.

Yep I know that's the case & I think its stupid for the divers to make this
assumption.
I feel all boats 'should' carry O2 & hence the skipper be familiar with it's
opperation, but that's not his 'primary' responsibility. For this 'tech' diving
the
team of divers should supply their own & in the first instance rely on their
'own' O2
and every member of the team be able to administrate if called upon. If you
make the
investment to this diving then there's a whole lot more that goes with it for a
diver than just stepping on a boat!


> It is a simple matter of diver/boat/skipper education.

I agree - but we're in early days. You have the advantage of being
knowledgeable to the
requirments of the tech community - this is a major bonus - alot of the other
skippers
are still learning.

Inexperience is the main worry. It takes time to learn & remember all the
protocols.
For the 'new' skipper to this game to be told a list of instructions for the
first
time, they can't be expected to remember everything they've been told until it
becomes
second nature. Maybe a idea is to hand them a breif aid memoire with the key
points
written down!

> Any mutterings soon dissappear when the diver finds he likes the extra
> security in the numbers and hanging gas.

It's having the right attitude for this style of diving. As the tech community
grows
here, many have come from the rec diving - 2 dives a day/DSMB - mentality. This
is not
what works best for tech diving and slowly they change there ideas and realise
the
merits! Unfortunately people normally like to learn the hard way!

 
> I would suggest speaking to the skipper about deployment of stations, it
> is a pain in the arse when the divers launch their system and it ends up
> in the screw.he should understand the system clearly or you shouldn`t go
> with him.

This is where diver/skipper comms are needed. We have our idea of whats best &
skippers
have there own. Most of the time a compromise can be found which is mutually
benifical
to both parties. I had one skipper that insisted the first pair of divers lept
in
dragging the trapeze - worked okay first time - second time was a complete
disaster as
it got caught round a fender & all got dragged through the water at a rate of
knotts!

We prefer to drop shot & have a little bit of line from the main buoy to a
small buoy
trailing as a pick up line. Rig trapeze on deck & have a long line from bottom
station
that will reach the surface. Come alongside shot & hook pick up line. While
boat stands station, quickly clip lead from trapeze to pick up line & lower
trapeze
overboard. First pair in unclips lead from pick up line & connects & takes down
shot,
to act as the jump line between shot & trapeze. This way while the boat is
manouvering
there are no divers in the water that the prop can snag on!

That seems to be quite straight forward in my mind - everthing is reasonably
calm &
collected! The only problem could be holding stations while the trapeze is
clipped &
lowered, but this takes a matter of 10/20 sec. Not being a skipper I have no
feel for
the crafts ability to achieve this, but I'd imagine if done wrongly the main
risk is
dragging the shot out of the wreck. Boats normally successful recover shots
without too
much problems so I imagine the above deployment is definately possible!

Comments would be appreciated. How do you deploy yours?


> Maybe the day is coming for techie skippers to be exactly
> that, i certainly think that any boat on tech diving should have crew.

Can't agree with you more. We're trying to persuade peeps to come onboard with
us to
help out, as a crew member is a rare occurance.

As we all continue to learn, hopefully both parties will benefit and it becomes
more common place for the skipper to assume his important position within the
team!

Role on more diver/boat/skipper education.

Cheers
Alex
--
Send mail for the `techdiver' mailing list to `techdiver@aquanaut.com'.
Send subscribe/unsubscribe requests to `techdiver-request@aquanaut.com'.

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]