Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

Date: Wed, 19 Mar 97 19:24:14 UT
From: "Lawrence Orchard" <DiveBase@ms*.co*>
To: "TechDiver List" <techdiver@aquanaut.com>
Subject: Hogarth Rig Problems...can you help.
A couple of years ago I started advanced diving, went out and bought all the 
wrong gear big time at great cost. Then went on an expensive liveaboard and 
training holiday, again at great cost, thinking I would come back a "tech" 
diver etc etc. I know, what an asshole. Now with hindsight, I realise the most 
valuable thing I got from that holiday was a slip of paper with the techdiver 
list email address (given to me by one of the American Cave Divers on the 
trip).

I returned to the UK, got Internet access and subscribed. What did I read ? 
Every bit of my equipment and its configuration indirectly slagged off. I was 
taken back a bit, but stuck with the list and over time, as the arguments for 
the Hogarthian approach revealed themselves, I rationalised my rig. 
Constrained by costs, as I'd blown a lot of money starting off, and with 
little or no advice available in the UK on the subject, I'm fairly pleased 
with what I now have.

I started with a DUI CF200 suit, 2 x 12 ltr 300bar (high pressure) manifolded 
(with face seals, not barrel), two short hose regs and an octopus, other hoses 
coming out everywhere, redundant Zeagle wings etc etc.

Now... I have an OMS SS backplate, one piece webbing (as per George's video) 
SeaPro wing, Spectrum 14 light, Argon bottle, regs all configured and routed 
correctly etc etc.

The problem now... the suit and the twinset.

Since using the backplate and SS bands, the set sits a couple of inches higher 
than it did with the Zeagles, thus tilting me forward. If I drilled holes 
lower down the backplate I would end up with the 1st stages too low for 
routing the hoses. So I thought I'll get another set, 2 x 12ltr 232 bar (low 
pressure) and thus distribute the weight further down my back (also get rid of 
the HP aspect). This worked well on a trial whilst on holiday in the Red Sea 
using two Aluminium 12ltr cylinders with a wet suit.

The buoyancy characteristics of my current set are just right from full to 
empty for staying at the surface and being able to stay down in low on gas 
deco situation. If I move to the LP 12ltrs the buoyancy difference is drastic 
so a V weight ain't going to help and I don't want to go back to using a 
weight belt. I've looked at the various cylinder types available in the UK and 
the ones that will give the weight distribution down the back and the right 
buoyancy characteristics are 12ltr 300 bar cylinders, just fill them to 232 
bar though.

As for changing the suit... apart from the cost, the main reason I bought the 
CF200 was because DUI told me it was tougher than a membrane suit and since my 
diving involves rummaging inside wrecks there was a high chance of getting a 
rip. Its not because I believe it offers any greater insulation, and I'm sure 
its less flexible.

Has anyone out there managed to make the Hogarthian approach work for them 
using a CF200 whilst diving in cold (7C) sea water? If so I'd really 
appreciate some help here, before I go and blow another load of hard earnt 
cash on a new set.

I'd just like to take this opportunity to say thank you to George, Carl Heinzl 
and Michael Dunning for their help in getting me thus far.

Best regards
Lawrence D. Orchard
Tel/Fax: +44 (0)1483 568435
Email: DiveBase@ms*.co*

--
Send mail for the `techdiver' mailing list to `techdiver@aquanaut.com'.
Send list subscription requests to `techdiver-request@aquanaut.com'.

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]