Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: cavers

Banner Advert

Message Display

From: trey@ne*.co* (Trey)
To: "Allen Wooten" <AWooten@ga*.cs*.st*.ga*.us*>
Cc: <cavers@cavers.com>
Subject: Re: Closing of the South of Tallahassee, Florida Caves
Date: Mon, 14 Aug 2000 15:07:00 -0400
Allen, you don't know what you are talking about.
The cave diving community got the caves closed due to
their disregard for the landowners and their track
record of death and detruction.

I got them opened back up.

They are opened up with the stipulation that we do
things the way I promised they would be done. That is
not open to debate with you or anyone else.

The real world is that I have overcome what your
source (who lied to you ) screwed up .



>My name is Allen Wooten and I live in Thomasville,
Ga.   I have my Dive
>Master Cert and Master Scuba Diver Cert.  Not too
long ago, I was cavern
>certified through NSS-CDS.  I am scheduled to take
Intro to Cave class
>this month at Ginnie Springs.
>
>Now that I've at least introduced myself, I'd like to
share with you my
>feelings/concerns regarding the closing of the South
of Tallahassee
>Caves to the overhead diving public.  Specifically, I
really wish they
>would be re-opened.
>
>What I want to communicate is based on the following
information I have
>been told by more than one person.  I understand that
your organization
>(WKPP) was instrumental in convincing the landowners
of those South
>Tallahassee caves that the WKPP was the only group
qualified to dive
>those springs/sinks, that the rest of the cave diving
community were
>basically strokes, and the liability was too high to
keep these places
>open to the public.
>
>I can't speak for the rest of the cave diving
community, but I can speak
>for myself.  Everyone has to begin somewhere.  I am
beginning where I am
>and look forward to the journey ahead.  I wish I had
$50,000 and 24
>hours/day to get the necessary training and equipment
to dive with you
>guys.  But I don't and can't.  I have to earn a
living for my family.
>It just so happens that I love to dive and seek these
opportunities in
>the North Florida area.  I would love to be able to
go just South of
>Tallahassee to a sink and get some overhead dives in
before I meet my
>wife at TGI Fridays for early evening dinner.
However, with the current
>closed-cave situation, I have to go further South,
spend more money, and
>get back home later to get in the necessary dives to
build experience.
>
>Let's face it, it is my belief that the cave diving
community regards
>the WKPP as the best in the world, but there is more
to diving in caves
>than being 15,000 feet back.  Many cavers just want
to go in and safely
>enjoy the experience.  To say that you can't dive the
Tallahassee caves
>unless you are part of WKPP is to say that there is
no other form or
>motivation for cave diving.  This argument simply
does not hold water.
>
>To say that the South Tallahassee sinks are more
fragile or require more
>skill than the other 250 caves in Florida may be
quite a stretch as
>well.  Why would these caves be more of a liability
than any of the
>other caves that are open to the public.  It seems
that a liability
>release is satisfactory for the rest of the legal
world.  Why would it
>apply differently in Tallahassee?  Or is this the
only sphere of
>influence that the WKPP has managed to create?
>
>Cave conservation is important.  I think any
respecting cave diver would
>agree, but conservation efforts are larger than any
one organization.
>If that were not so, then the government could simply
mandate it across
>the board.  The fact is that they can't and neither
can any one
>organization.  It requires teamwork.  I have my
Master of Business
>Administration (MBA) degree.  I know enough to know
that an organization
>doesn't accomplish its mission through superiority
complexes,
>alienation, and an exclusiveness culture; but rather,
it must work
>together with all stakeholders (including the cave
community).  The end
>does not always justify the means.  The non-diving
public doesn't have
>enough knoweldge about the situation to make educated
decisions.  They
>will believe anything you tell them and are mostly
motivated by fear.
>
>If indeed the WKPP convinced the landowners to close
these sinks, then
>it is my feeling that the WKPP is biting the very
hand that fed them
>individually for so many years.  After all, the cave
diving community
>taught you the skills necessary to cave dive safely.
You simply
>expanded upon them to do more extreme missions.  And
that is good, but
>it isn't comprehensive of every possible motivation
to cave dive.  Some
>people just want to cave dive for fun.
>
>Sheck Exley was a true industry leader.  He didn't
resort to exclusion.
>Rather, he fought to keep the sport of cave diving
legal for ALL who
>wanted to participate by creating and educating
others regarding safe
>cave diving practices and conservation through the
NSS-CDS.  This was
>during a time when increasing deaths almost made the
sport illegal by
>society (as if society had any authority to make
decisions regarding the
>risks that an individual takes upon himself).  By
getting sinks closed,
>it seems to me that the WKPP is working directly
against what Exley
>fought so hard to achieve.
>
>As far as I'm concerned, the Wakulla Springs and all
sinks in Leon
>County are a waste of a resource in total.  Sure,
they provide Florida
>with drinking water.  But so what?  Water is useful
for more things than
>drinking.  It can be used for recreation.  Since I'll
never get to see
>the features of the Leon sinks, how will that
resource ever touch my
>life personally?  Life is about making the best of it
and being happy.
>Being restricted from dive sites and doing the things
you love doesn't
>create happiness.  It creates sadness in an already
hateful world.  The
>goal of any organization should be to make man's
existence more
>beneficial, peaceful, and happy.  Taking away their
freedom doesn't
>accomplish this.  I don't think I can support an
organization that
>actively attempts to take my freedoms away.  America
used to be the land
>of the free and the brave.  I do not believe this to
any longer be the
>case.  It seems to now be the land of the regulated
and the soft.
>
>I don't mean any of this as a personal attack in any
way.  Every
>organization must face its critics.  This is part of
organizational
>dynamics and behavior.  I, like you, am trying to
make a difference and
>be the best that I can be.  I don't expect this
E-mail to be the
>save-all of the opening of the Leon County Sinks, but
I do hope you will
>file this one away with any others you may have
received and will
>receive.  At a minimum, thanks for hearing me out.
>
>Thanks,
>Allen
>

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]